If you鈥檙e heading somewhere with lots of insects鈥攕ay, a swamp in the Everglades or the Amazon鈥攜ou鈥檒l likely want to use an insect repellent. have shown that the most effective insect repellent on the market today is DEET, but others have raised questions over the potential health and environmental impacts of the stuff.
DEET, known to chemists as N,N-diethyl-meta-toluamide, was developed in the 1940s by and for the U.S. Army. It鈥檚 since become widely used by everyone from hunters and campers to fishermen and long-distance hikers to combat mosquitoes and ticks. The and the both say DEET is safe for use and causes no known environmental or health risks, as long as it鈥檚 used properly per the directions on the label.
But there鈥檚 one thing DEET is likely bad for: your outerwear. According to the , DEET, a plasticizer, can cause damage to other plastics, including synthetic or treated fabrics. (It won鈥檛 damage natural fibers, like cotton or wool.) Spray DEET on a Gore-Tex jacket, for example, and the repellent could break down the plastic polymer that makes up the membrane, the thin layer that keeps your jacket waterproof and breathable.
鈥淚nsect repellents made for skin application are not developed for clothing, so you don鈥檛 want to put DEET on any clothing except cotton,鈥 says Vern Schrum, product manager at , makers of insect repellents like and . 鈥淚f your jacket has some kind of membrane that allows it to breathe, DEET could damage that, sealing it up so it doesn鈥檛 work as well.鈥
It doesn鈥檛 require dumping your jacket in a vat of DEET for this to happen鈥攁ny prolonged contact with even traces of the chemical can degrade plastic-based membranes and affect the breathability of your coat, Schrum says. 鈥淚t takes time to set up, so if you get a bit of DEET on your jacket, you can wipe it off no problem,鈥 he says. 鈥淏ut it doesn鈥檛 take much鈥攅ven a small amount can cause damage.鈥
Gore has performed tests that show that after 24 hours of exposure to DEET, its specific membrane doesn't break down. But not many other tests are being done on DEET's impact on technical clothing, so hard data on prolonged exposure is tough to find. 鈥淲e have many tests where we spray DEET on fabric to see if mosquitoes will still bite through the fabric. But the impact on the clothing? We don鈥檛 study that,鈥 says Immo Hansen, an associate professor of biology at New Mexico State University who studies the efficacy of insect repellents.
You can still use DEET鈥攋ust apply it to your skin and don鈥檛 spray it near your $600 three-layer hard shell. And if you really want the extra protection of repellent-coated clothing, what can you do instead? In 2016, the efficacy of insect-repellent clothing from brands like and , which are pretreated with the insecticide permethrin, an alternative to DEET that鈥檚 intended for use on clothing. The report found that permethrin-treated clothes were not as effective at preventing insect bites as a shirt sprayed with DEET, but they did ward off some bugs. You can treat your own clothes with permethrin by using a clothing-specific spray from brands like or . The downside: Permethrin is far more toxic to aquatic invertebrates鈥攂ugs found in streams and lakes鈥攖han DEET. According to a statement from ExOfficio, home permethrin treatments are riskier due to chemical runoff and overuse, but that鈥檚 not the case with pretreated garments.
Plenty of other clothing alternatives offer varying degrees of longevity and effectiveness in protecting from insect bites. Natural repellents made with essential oils like , , and are considerably gentler than DEET (though, again, not as effective). In 2005, the CDC approved the use of picaridin, used in products from and , which is safer on gear and still provides up to 12 hours of protection from biting insects. Hansen says DEET is the most effective and long-lasting of the repellents, but oil of lemon eucalyptus is nearly comparable. 鈥淢any of the natural products are very good,鈥 he says. 鈥淭hey just don鈥檛 last as long.鈥