Eric Larsen, the who recently attempted an unsupported speed ski trip to the South Pole, says his anxiety increases a hundredfold听when he鈥檚 on an expedition. 鈥淚t鈥檚 hard to describe what it鈥檚 like, but it鈥檚 uncertainty about your outcome, your gear, and what the duration of your trip will be,鈥 he says. 鈥淚t鈥檚 death by a thousand cuts, because it wears down your spirits over a long time.鈥
Stephen Haddelsey, a British historian who last fall听published ,听a book about early polar exploration, says the early arctic explorers called that feeling polar madness.听They knew their temperaments changed during dark, cold听days, and they struggled with isolation, complicated team dynamics, and fear. It turns out they were also听often听dealing with what we now call seasonal affective disorder (SAD). Frederick A. Cook, the surgeon on the Belgica Expedition of 1897, the first to spend winter in Antarctica, wrote in his notes from the trip: 鈥淭he human system accommodates itself sluggishly and poorly to the strange conditions of the polar seasons, and we, too, are slow in adapting ourselves to the awful despondency of the long winter night.鈥
We鈥檝e learned a lot about the edges of the known world since then, but we鈥檙e still trying to figure out how to deal with the toll this kind of exploration takes on the psyche. Research on mental health in isolated and听environmentally harsh conditions is a developing field, but it promises insight into how humans might better cope with other extreme situations鈥攍ike interplanetary exploration or听a sufferfest backcountry mission.
In the early 1900s, explorers were trying to understand who might be prone to depression听and how that might present itself on trips and impact teams. 鈥淭hey recognized early that in the long polar winters, people started behaving badly,鈥 Haddelsey says. 鈥淭hey knew it was associated with dark winter, but they didn鈥檛 know it was physiological.鈥 In those harsh environments, your body responds biologically to a lack of sunlight and a constant state of stress. Some people are more prone to negative psychological impacts, and Haddelsey explains that part of the struggle of managing depression and anxiety on those early trips was parsing out the difference between SAD and other kinds of mental-health problems鈥攅specially considering that at the time there was little scientific knowledge of either.听Ernest Shackleton, who led three expeditions to Antarctica, conducted his own crew interviews using a personality rubric for finding men he thought were self-reliant, intelligent, and calm. Now, modern explorers like Larsen track and monitor their mental health to sort out the same questions. But highly intelligent, independent, emotionally stable people still struggle with isolation and darkness, and there are no concrete rules for avoiding it, Haddelsey听says.
Research on mental health in isolated and听environmentally harsh conditions is a developing field, but it promises insight into how humans might better cope with other extreme situations鈥攍ike interplanetary exploration or a sufferfest backcountry mission.
Nathan Smith, who studies the psychology of expeditions at the University of Manchester, says that the field has exploded since he began his research in 2013. Part of that is driven by NASA, which is funding research in Antarctica that it鈥檒l apply to its work on Mars, because the Arctic can simulate conditions similar to space. Smith and his colleagues are evaluating how humans handle physiological and psychological challenges like cold, physical strain, and isolation, and developing strategies to mitigate their impact.
To do that, the researchers听created a series of questions about mental health and group dynamics for arctic expedition members to fill out daily. These expedition journals, like the most recent ones from two 13-person teams at , offered Smith an expedition-wide profile of emotional peaks and troughs, which enabled him and his team to identify their sources, quantify the emotional stress experienced throughout the expedition, and even start to predict behaviors.听
Smith says that when people report changes in emotion, they don鈥檛 tend to report huge swings, but even the slightest change can provide insight. 鈥淲hen you see a small spike and it鈥檚 moving in the direction of negative, it means a lot,鈥 Smith says鈥攅specially when that shift is reflected across the board.
Expedition members often hold their emotions close, because they don鈥檛 want to burden their team.
He explains that expedition members often hold their emotions close, because they don鈥檛 want to burden their team. The diaries give them an outlet to air concerns, which largely turned out to be shared across the team. In extreme environments, people are often听preoccupied with thoughts of friends and family living a normal life without them, and the feelings grow when they lack privacy. Small triggers鈥攍ike a frustrating project or a sense of inertia鈥攃an lead to bigger mental-health spirals, because the circumstances preclude common coping strategies, like restorative alone time.听
The researchers are building off past knowledge. While reading through old trip logs, Haddelsey found that factors he assumed would contribute to depression鈥攍ike hard work and remoteness鈥攑ositively influenced the crew鈥檚 disposition. It turns out that feeling like you鈥檙e part of a team, staying busy, and being able to focus on an engrossing task without outside distraction, are all good for the brain. 鈥淭hose bases that have the poorest communication with the outside world have better mental health records,鈥 he says.
Admiral John Ross, who spent several winters in the Arctic in the 1830s and is credited with locating magnetic north, worked hard to prevent his men from turning inward. He helped them stay engaged with their crew by staging amateur theater projects听and kept them busy with scientific work like meticulous record-keeping. These strategies 鈥渨ouldn鈥檛 have prevented the onset of SAD, but it would have reduced it,鈥 says Haddelsey.
Coping techniques haven鈥檛 changed much听from the early days of polar exploration. Larsen skips the base-camp vaudeville, but he starts his journeys as fit听as possible听to avoid physical challenges that might derail him psychologically. Once his trip is underway, he breaks it down into small听manageable parts听to avoid feeling overwhelmed by the sheer volume of time and space ahead of him. He鈥檚 also careful to balance positivity with realism. 鈥淎t home, I鈥檓 an optimist off the charts, but the worst is when you have hope and it鈥檚 not realized. That emotional letdown really crushes you,鈥 he says. (Larsen recently called off a solo speed attempt across the South Pole due to inclement weather and safety concerns.)
From a scientific perspective, Smith says that so far, there鈥檚 no single thing that wards off听the mental-health challenges presented by these environments. His research has shown that what he calls emotion-focused coping strategies,听or ways to reframe the situation and distract yourself, are among the most successful techniques. That might look like Larsen鈥檚 small听manageable goals鈥攕ay, moving one ski past the other鈥攐r it might mean adopting a moving meditation, like using music or mantras to get out of your head. But the most critical factor, according to Smith, is something that Admiral Ross figured out on his own: when the situation grows dire, some action鈥攅ven the wrong action鈥攊s better than no action. 鈥淚f we perceive we have the ability to cope, we will respond adaptively,鈥 Smith says. 鈥淲hen we鈥檙e overwhelmed, we shut down and stop trying.鈥