Jim Cummins was not only the founder of one of the world鈥檚 best-known gravel-bike races, the Dirty Kanza, but he was also its public face鈥攖he man at the finish line in Emporia, Kansas, waiting to give each returning rider a hero鈥檚 welcome after 200 miles of rutted roads, headwinds, and tire-sucking mud. That is, until June 17, when Cummins posted a video on his personal Facebook page听calling the shooting听of Rayshard Brooks,听a 27-year-old Black man who was听killed听 on June 12听when Brooks听was found sleeping in a Wendy鈥檚 drive through lane,听鈥渏ustified鈥 and inviting anyone who disagreed to 鈥渦nfriend鈥 him. Many followers did so, and even more expressed hurt and anger about the post on social media.听
Cummins鈥檚 reach in the bike world is considerable. The race he dreamed up in 2006 as a solo, self-supported tour of Kansas鈥檚听rolling Flint Hills has since grown into a marquee event听attracting not only top professional racers but amateur riders from听all over the country鈥攖he closest thing the burgeoning gravel scene had to a World Tour. Last year听the Dirty Kanza attracted thousands听of riders to its 25-, 50-, 100-, 200-, and 350-mile events. The race put Emporia on the map as a top U.S. cycling destination, a new and unexpected reputation the 24,000-person town was happy to adopt.听
In 2018, Life Time, a national chain of races and fitness companies, the once scrappy gravel grinder and kept Cummins on as its 鈥渃hief gravel officer.鈥 Until that post went up. Within 24 hours, Life Time had 鈥減arted ways鈥 with Cummins, according to the senior vice president Kimo Seymour. The company describing his Facebook comments as 鈥渋nappropriate and insensitive,鈥 and clarified its听mission of making gravel racing 鈥渁 more inclusive and progressive place where all feel welcome and represented.鈥
Cummins declined an interview, but in a statement shared with Road Bike Action, he , 鈥淚听chose my words poorly鈥 and 鈥淸I]听hope that, some day, I can听help to heal the wounds that I have caused.鈥 But his words landed during a summer marked by civil rights protests and in a cycling world grappling with a historical lack of inclusivity, particularly for Black and Indigenous riders.听
His dismissal also reignited another听long-simmering, racially charged controversy surrounding the Dirty Kanza.听
Race director LeLan Dains has a long history with both this region of听Kansas and the race. An Emporia local, he first competed in the 200-miler in 2008听and joined the four-person staff five years later. Then听someone approached the event team about the problematic nature of the name of the race itself, which some argue is a racist slur against the听Kaw people native to the land on which the race is held.听Translated as the 鈥,鈥 the Kaw were given the name 鈥淜anza,鈥 or 鈥淜ansa,鈥 by early French traders and other European settlers. But听it鈥檚 the pairing of 鈥渄irty鈥 with the tribal name that many argue turns the race鈥檚 title into a historical racist stereotype.听
Dains says that there were no ill intentions behind the name of the race. 鈥淲e named it 鈥榙irty鈥 for the gravel roads and the dirt you get on your legs and body when you ride them,鈥 he says, 鈥渁nd 鈥楰anza鈥 for the state, which gets its name from the Kaw tribe.鈥澨
Still, over the years, Dains says members of the organization made several unsuccessful attempts to contact the Kaw Nation鈥檚 leadership for their thoughts on the name.听
In 2019,听Cummins听was finally able to meet with Lynn Williams, chair of the Kaw Nation Tribal Council. The two convened at Kaw Nation headquarters in Kaw City, Oklahoma, on February 26 of that year听and ultimately agreed that the name would stay as is. Seymour says, 鈥淭he last time we spoke, Williams said the Kaw Nation took no offense to the name.鈥 (Williams did not respond to requests for comment.)
But continuing criticism听raised the question of whether Williams鈥檚 decision accurately reflected her community鈥檚 feelings as a whole. In fact, according to by听Bicycling, a few months before he met with Williams,听Cummins was forwarded an email on November 9, 2018, 鈥渟igned by 45 members of the Kaw Nation, along with academics, advocates, and allies鈥 saying that听鈥渢he name was offensive to many people in or associated with the Kaw Nation,鈥 James Stout wrote for听Bicycling. (Dains says he鈥檚 not 鈥減ersonally aware of a petition that potentially contained 45 members of the Kaw Nation.鈥)
In April of 2020, Christina Torres, the founder of听, an independent publication focused on 鈥渟haring knowledge and the stories of BIPOC and FTW [femme, trans, and women]听folx in cycling,鈥 launched a urging the race to change its name. The issue felt personal to Torres, as an avid cyclist and a Kawaiisu Shoshone-Paiute descendant of the Tejon听Indian Tribe, she . 鈥淭he Kaw Nation of Kansas, now of Oklahoma, has survived adversity and today is a federally recognized, self-governing tribe seeking to recover its cultural heritage and land,鈥 . 鈥淭o preface the Kanza people with 鈥榙irty鈥 shows a disconnect of America鈥檚 legacy of anti-Indigenous violence.鈥
The petition drew more than 1,200 signatures鈥攎any from Indigenous people across the country鈥攁nd the attention of the team in Emporia. In response, Cummins issued in April 2020 revealing his 2019 meeting with Williams听and said that the race name would not be changing. The statement also clarified his听intentions behind choosing its name. Though Williams鈥檚 signature appears on the open letter, her voice seemed to be absent.
At the time, the Dirty Kanza wasn鈥檛 the only gravel event confronting the impact its name might have on Indigenous groups. In late 2019, Bobby Wintle, founder of the gravel race in Oklahoma, announced that听he had changed the race鈥檚 official title to .听Wintle VeloNews that when he first named the race, he was 鈥渦naware that the name held negative connotations for many still living today.鈥 The Oklahoma land rush听was named as such because a , effective April 22, 1889, allowed 50,000 white settlers to seize two million acres of Indigenous land. (The land run of 1893 saw settlers take a further six million acres.)听鈥淥nce our small crew and myself realized that the correlation with the original land run of 1889 was offensive to others, we had to make a change,鈥 Wintle said in .
To many, the Dirty Kanza was one more example of the way Native-derived names often ignore the voices of the very people they purport to honor, raising the question of who gets to grant permission听to use those names. 鈥淥ne person from the Native community saying, 鈥業 think it鈥檚 OK鈥 is no different than someone saying, 鈥楾hat鈥檚 not racist, because I have a Black friend,鈥欌 says artist, gravel rider, and Indigenous activist Gregg Deal. 鈥淵ou鈥檙e talking about an entire community of people, which means there are different ideas and schools of thought.鈥
Deal bemoans the fact that Indigenous people aren鈥檛 given agency or authority in matters so deeply tied to their culture. 鈥淧eople will tell you straight to your face, 鈥業t鈥檚 not offensive, that鈥檚 not the intent,鈥欌 he says. 鈥淢ost Americans in that school of thought feel like they get to decide what鈥檚 offensive, what鈥檚 not offensive, and what鈥檚 an honor, what鈥檚 not an honor. But that can鈥檛 exist without a true dialogue or relationship of some kind.鈥澨
That dialogue is finally being attempted on more of a national scale. Just this week, the NFL鈥檚 Washington, D.C., team announced plans for a to replace its long-protested racist one, California鈥檚 Squaw Valley Ski Resort reportedly for a less offensive moniker, and Yeti Cycles they鈥檇 stop using the word 鈥渢ribe鈥 in their marketing.
Torres declined an interview, and while she didn鈥檛 provide her reasons, the naming saga had become heated and sometimes personal.听Once Cummins issued his open letter, many thought the issue was settled: the Kaw Nation had granted an ostensible stamp of approval on the race name. This prompted a fair amount of online backlash to the petition. Commenters unleashed their usual gripes about cancel culture, some of which spilled over into personal criticism of Torres. 鈥淪top looking for ways to be offended!鈥 read one听of the tamer responses on Instagram.听
And then came Cummins鈥檚 June 19 Facebook post, which renewed the听push to change the race鈥檚 name.听Activists began a second petition.听Titled , the petition is a 鈥渃ampaign to end the use of the slur 鈥榙irty Kanza鈥 as the event name of DIRTY KANZA (DK) in Emporia, KS.鈥 The authors听have decided to remain anonymous听but听are described as a 鈥渦nited collective of Indigenous advocates, cyclists, people of faith, educators, elders, youth, local Kansas residents and builders of a just world.鈥 I reached out to the authors听through an intermediary, and they declined to comment. As of today, the petition has been signed by more than 6,500 people.听
This time, the team in Emporia was ready to listen. In a June 22 , race organizers committed to changing the name. Dains confirmed over the phone on June 24 that they were in the process of landing on a new race title, which they would announce in 鈥渆ight to ten weeks.鈥澨鼿e added that the petition had accelerated the decision, but that the name-change conversation had remained open for some time.听
鈥淲e know now more than ever that words have meaning,鈥 Dains says. 鈥淎t the time we made that announcement in unison with the Kaw Nation, we felt we were right in continuing with the name. But at the end of the day, we can be legally 鈥榬ight,鈥 or听we can be kind. We鈥檙e going to choose to be kind and change the name.鈥澨
For many, that change can鈥檛 come fast enough. Support for the petition and further demands鈥攊ncluding more acknowledgement of the Indigenous groups who have long opposed the name and have had their complaints ignored鈥攃ontinues to grow after the announcement, even among past riders and winners. Amity Rockwell, the winner of last year鈥檚 race, requests for the organizers, including a name change and a BIPOC athlete-sponsorship program.听
The decision to change the name is a 鈥済ood move, in good faith,鈥 says Deal, adding that it鈥檚 one 鈥渢hat won鈥檛 change the hard, grueling nature of the race.鈥 It鈥檚 a move toward better accountability to the Indigenous communities whose names and images have long been appropriated to represent the outdoors.听But it鈥檚 not the finish line. That will come into sight, Deal says, when Indigenous people are given true agency听over the use of their names and symbols, and when bike races create more opportunities and accessibility for riders of color.听