Chances are you or someone you know received a wearable fitness device this holiday season.聽These devices, perennially atop gift-giving lists and integral to New Year鈥檚 resolutions, measure everything from steps taken to heart-beats beaten to hours slept. In doing so, they motivate better habits and drive healthy behavior change鈥攐r so the theory goes.聽
But recent survey that more than half of individuals who use聽a wearable stop using it at some point after purchasing it, and, among those, one third do so within six months. Even if someone ardently uses their wearable, that doesn鈥檛 necessarily mean they鈥檒l see results. Consider published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, in which researchers from the University of Pittsburgh found that among overweight people following the same diet, those who used a fitness tracker lost less weight compared to those who did not. (The researchers were not sure about聽the cause.) In another JAMA article, 鈥淲earable Devices as Facilitators, Not Drivers, of Heath Behavior Change,鈥 researchers from the University of Pennsylvania , 鈥淭he gap between recording information and changing behavior is substantial, and while these [wearable] devices are increasing in popularity, little evidence suggests they are bridging that gap.鈥澛
There is, however, at least one fitness tracker that seems particularly effective in helping people across all fitness levels reach their goals. It鈥檚 surprisingly low-tech, and, perhaps because of that, is far too often an afterthought: a friend.
For a comprehensive analysis published in the journal Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, researchers reviewed over 30 studies in search of factors that consistently motivate people to start and stick with exercise programs. What they found is that one of the strongest motivators to keep with a fitness routine is having the support of friends and family. This idea was clearly demonstrated in two specific studies. The , published in 2007聽in the聽New England Journal of Medicine, found that聽when someone becomes obese, his or her friends are 57 percent more likely to become obese as well. The ,聽published in聽Psychology of Sport and Exercise聽in 2011, demonstrated that the聽flipside聽of this is true, too: an individual鈥檚 exercise habits can often be predicted by examining his or her social circle鈥攑eople who have friends that exercise tend to exercise as well.聽In other words,聽fitness is contagious.
It鈥檚 a lot harder to ignore a training partner than it is to ignore a wrist strap.
鈥淎 commitment to a device isn鈥檛 nearly as powerful as a commitment to a person,鈥 says , a behavioral scientist and professor at the University of Massachusetts Medical School. 鈥淲e are very affected by those around us, especially when we go through a shared struggle like the process of developing fitness.鈥 According to Pagoto, while social media and other virtual networks may be helpful motivators for some, to date, nothing matches the motivational power of a training partner or group. 鈥淚t鈥檚 hard to replicate the intimate ties, subsequent support, and perhaps most importantly, accountability that comes with real, live training partners,鈥 she says. In other words, it鈥檚 a lot harder to ignore a training partner than it is to ignore a wrist strap.
As for finding the ideal training partner, a from Kansas State University suggests you鈥檇 be wise to find someone who is a bit better than you. Researchers found that when people exercised with someone whom they perceived as slightly fitter than themselves, they increased their workout duration and intensity by up to 200 percent. 鈥淭here is definitely a competitive element that, for many, probably lends itself to increased performance,鈥 says Pagoto.聽
It should come as no surprise, then, that some of the best training environments tend to be groups of individuals pushing each other toward common goals. While this helps explain the success of recreational programs like and your local CrossFit gym, it is perhaps an even greater factor in elite sports. Recently, more and more 鈥渢raining squads,” as they鈥檙e called鈥攍ike (track and field), the (distance running), and the (triathlon)鈥攁re producing world-class athletes and results.聽
鈥淭raining is hard. Let鈥檚 not pretend that we all have bulletproof internal motivation, that we will 鈥榖ring it鈥 every single day,鈥 says , a sprint coach and director of performance at ALTIS聽who,聽along with聽a few聽other coaches and athletes, is credited with helping Andre De聽Grasse聽take silver in the 200-meter run during the 2016 Rio Games (he came聽). 鈥淔or those days when athletes need a little pick-me-up, their teammates are there. And they know this.鈥澛
鈥淭he energy that comes with being in a group of committed like-minded individuals clearly enhances the training process, and in some cases enables athletes to do more than they could on their own or do the same work more effectively,鈥 says Joe Filliol, the coach of the JFTcrew, a training squad that over the last four years has produced 38 World Triathlon Series podium finishes, nine Olympians, and a world champion.
Then again, this sentiment is nothing new. Long before we had high-tech training tools, the founding fathers of the American running boom relied heavily upon group workouts, and it undergirded much of their success. In his memoir, My Marathon: Reflections on a Gold Medal Life, Frank Shorter writes, 鈥淲orking with [legendary runners] Kenny Moore and Steve Prefontaine convinced me of the enormous benefits of elite-level, like-minded training partners.鈥澛
So, as you set out to pursue your 2017 fitness goals, you鈥檇 be wise to spend at least as much time and energy shopping for the perfect training partner or group as you would shopping for the perfect wearable. Odds are, the former will do more for your long-term performance than the latter. As Filliol told me, 鈥渟urrounded by commitment, success is inevitable.鈥澛